back to top
Free Shipping 3-Day • Orders over $149
Some orders may experience increased time in shipment due to carrier delays. Thank you for your patience.
Back To Expert Reviews

CAO Consigliere

Kelly Expert Picks: Around The World Expert Pick

Smoke like a boss with CAO Consigliere! This tri-country blend of long-fillers are dressed in a dark, oily Brazilian Mata Fina maduro wrapper. Heavy on the palate, a nutty core is surrounded with hearty notes of earth and slight hints of cinnamon. Solid construction with an effortless draw, this premium is a bonafide showstopper!

Smoke like a boss with CAO Consigliere! This tri-country blend of long-fillers are dressed in a dark, oily Brazilian Mata Fina maduro wrapper. Heavy on the palate, a nutty core is surrounded with hearty notes of earth and slight hints of cinnamon. Solid construction with an effortless draw, this premium is a bonafide showstopper!

Shop Now Shop Now
Reviewed By
Kelly
Preferred Cigar Profile:
Send me your feedback

More Reviews By Kelly

Rocky Patel Sun Grown Maduro

Kelly Expert Picks: A Taste of It All Expert Pick
This '95' rated delight starts with an oily Connecticut Broadleaf wrapper that covers dual binders and Nicaraguan long-fillers. Defining what it means to be a "full-bodied" cigar, this maduro keeps its construction along with a bold flavor profile from head to foot—prepare for a complex yet balanced experience. A true mainstay for full-bodied fanatics.…
Read More

Punch Gran Puro

Kelly Expert Picks: Summer Stogies Expert Pick
This Top 25 premium is a staple for my summers! The highest primings of both the sun-grown Havana-seed wrapper and Honduran binder are carefully selected, setting the tone for one medium to full-bodied experience filled with round, spicy flavors featuring hints of cinnamon, making the '93' rated Punch Gran Puro prime for a perfect day.…
Read More

Alec Bradley Prensado Cigars

Kelly Expert Picks: The Men of the Hour Expert Pick
This box-pressed beauty by Alan Rubin is what comes to mind every time I'm in need of a premium that hits the spot. '96' rated, this lush blend burns slow and even, making way to a palatable treat filled with toasty nuances of leather, earth, and hints of chocolate. Spicy on the forefront, this premium offsets its power with some sweet nuances.…
Read More

Alec Bradley Nica Puro

Kelly Expert Picks: Spring Starters Expert Pick
Alec Bradley Nica Puro brings forth copious amounts of flavor with each puff. Concise notes of leather and cocoa, with slight cashew nuances create a robust yet smooth experience that results in one pleasing experience. Carrying a '91' rating, it's no wonder why this premium tops the charts!…
Read More

Joya de Nicaragua Antano 1970

Kelly Expert Picks: Through the Years Expert Pick
This premium is worth celebrating, as this was the initial brand made in the first cigar factory that opened in Nicaragua in 1969. Continuing to top the charts on my favorites list with its full-bodied profile, cedar and earth nuances, and spice on the finish, Antaño is perfect when you want to sit back and reminisce!…
Read More

San Cristobal Elegancia

Kelly Expert Picks: Holiday Handmades Expert Pick
A slight break from the fuller-bodied blends I enjoy, this did not disappoint in the least bit! The seamless Ecuador Connecticut wrapper and Nicaraguan blend led to some pepper notes upfront. About 1/4 of the way through, hints of pepper were balanced out by a heavy, smooth draw, full of flavor in each puff.…
Read More

E.P. Carrillo La Historia

Kelly Expert Picks: Must-Have Maduros Expert Pick
Before I get carried away, let's admire the premium at hand: A San Andrés wrapper, Ecuador Sumatra binder, and long-fillers from Nicaragua and the Dominican. As for the flavors, prepare your palate for a rich, satisfying experience filled with notes of black cherry, coffee, cocoa, and hints of spice—this is one for the books!…
Read More

H. Upmann 1844 Reserve

Kelly Expert Picks: Habano Heat Wave Expert Pick
H. Upmann 1844 Reserve made a lasting impression in my group of handmades. This cigar performed like a champion with top-notch construction. The deep, ample tobacco flavors from the tri-country long-filler blend of Peruvian, Nicaraguan, and Dominican leaves provided an experience that was smooth and flawless.…
Read More

Diesel Cigars Unlimited

Kelly Expert Picks: Summer Starters Expert Pick
Hearty filler tobaccos from Nicaragua and long-leaf from the San Andrès Valley, along with a Cuban-seed Ligero wrapper offers one heck of a cigar which packs robust notes of earth, leather, and oak...all with a spicy kick. This is one premium from Diesel that delivers optimum flavor and performance—a limitless experience!…
Read More

Punch

Kelly Expert Picks: All-Time Greats Expert Pick
There was no doubt the #12 Cigar of 2018 had to make it in this lineup! Robust and full-flavored, this Ecuadorian-wrapped premium contains a tri-country blend of fillers that produce earthy aromas with underlying hints of spice. Strong but not overpowering, this cigar lives up to its name, packing a punch in all the right ways!…
Read More

H. Upmann Legacy Nicaragua

Kelly Expert Picks: Spring Into Sun Grown Expert Pick
Never receiving an official release, this limited-edition premium was one I just had to try. Aged for no less than three years, filled with 100% Nicaraguan tobaccos, this cigar 'wow-ed' in every way! Rich flavors flourished from head to foot with nuances of almonds, cedar, spice, and earth. This is one Legacy that's legendary!…
Read More

Camacho Ecuador

Kelly Expert Picks: Spring Favorites Expert Pick
As a fan of full-bodied cigars, I sampled Camacho Ecuador and realized I made a huge mistake by not trying one sooner! Medium to full-bodied, the electric blue bands aren't the only thing bold about this blend. Expect big flavors of coffee and chocolate with a rich, bready aroma—this cigar is more than good, it's great!…
Read More
100% satisfaction guaranteed
Get the Latest Deals!
Sign Up for email