back to top
Free Shipping 3-Day • Orders over $149
Some orders may experience increased time in shipment due to carrier delays. Thank you for your patience.
Back To Expert Reviews

Hoyo La Amistad Gold

John Expert Picks: Silver & Gold Expert Pick

Created by AJ Fernandez, this is a modern take on a classic brand—and as you might expect—it’s jaw-droppingly complex. Featuring a blend of long-fillers from Nicaragua's top growing regions and an oily Ecuador Habano wrapper, this cigar's sweet, spicy, and full-boded profile makes it a can't-miss.

Created by AJ Fernandez, this is a modern take on a classic brand—and as you might expect—it’s jaw-droppingly complex. Featuring a blend of long-fillers from Nicaragua's top growing regions and an oily Ecuador Habano wrapper, this cigar's sweet, spicy, and full-boded profile makes it a can't-miss.

Shop Now Shop Now
Reviewed By
John
John
Preferred Cigar Profile:

More Reviews By John

Don Pepin Garcia Blue

John Expert Picks: Winter Winners Expert Pick
Full-bodied, complex, and well-made, Don Pepin Garcia Blue is worthy of all the praise it's received since its launch. The blend utilizes high quality Nicaraguan long-fillers with a toothy Corojo wrapper over top, giving this '93' rated gem a spicy aroma with hints of cinnamon, earth, and dried fruit. One of Don Pepin's finest cigars to date.…
Read More

Alec Bradley Black Market Esteli

John Expert Picks: Favorite Fallbacks Expert Pick
Alec Bradley's Black Market cigars have always been a favorite of mine, but this '93' rated gem steals the show. Brimming with a four-country blend of long-fillers wrapped in a dark Nicaraguan leaf, this premium is satisfying to the core with notes of leather, chocolate, and earth.…
Read More

Romeo y Julieta Reserve

John Expert Picks: Absolute All-Stars Expert Pick
With its oily Nicaraguan Habano wrapper and mix of Honduran and Nicaraguan tobaccos, Romeo y Julieta Reserve is always a treat. It offers smooth and rich notes of oak, coffee, black pepper, and a bit of sweetness. A balance of strength and flavor, this cigar is one of Romeo y Julieta's best creations.…
Read More

Macanudo Cru Royale

John Expert Picks: A Summer to Savor Expert Pick
Macanudo Crü Royale is a medium-bodied gem which features a dark Ecuador Habano wrapper with Dominican and Brazilian fillers beneath. Crü Royale is rich with deep notes of sweet earth, black pepper, and wood. This cigar never fails to impress, as it is consistently flavorful and well-made. A must for any Macanudo fan.…
Read More

Rocky Patel Vintage '90

John Expert Picks: Father's Favorites Expert Pick
Masterfully blended and perfectly balanced, Rocky Patel Vintage '90 is an exceptional cigar which has earned a regular place in my humidor. Featuring a 12-year-aged Honduran Broadleaf maduro wrapper with a blend of well-aged fillers and binders, you'll experience rich notes of cedar, espresso, and some sweetness.…
Read More

Rocky Patel Dark Dominican

John Expert Picks: Choice Churchills Expert Pick
Encased with a dark and oily Dominican wrapper with Dominican long-fillers tucked beneath, Dark Dominican is a decadent mellow to medium-bodied blend with notes of sweet cedar, earth, and nuts. One of my favorite cigars from Rocky Patel.…
Read More

Victor Sinclair Serie '55' Imperial Connecticut

John Expert Picks: Spring Fever Expert Pick
This cigar is an easygoing blend that never disappoints. Decadent Dominican long-fillers are encased by a smooth Connecticut wrapper. Satisfying notes of leather, spice, and cedar greet the palate and pair nicely with a morning coffee. One of Victor Sinclair’s crowning achievements.…
Read More

CAO Flathead

John Expert Picks: Year of the Favorites Expert Pick
This is not only one of my top picks for 2017, it's also one of my go-to cigars. This '95' rated box-pressed beauty sports a well-aged Connecticut Broadleaf wrapper with Nicaraguan and Dominican long-fillers beneath. Its notes of cocoa, black pepper, and earth are always an absolute pleasure.…
Read More

Enclave Broadleaf by AJ Fernandez

John AJ's Innovation on Full Display
AJ Fernandez is a very busy man–and that may be putting it lightly. Recently, he’s collaborated with some of the biggest names in the business to make some absolute gems, and he’s somehow found the time to craft some new premiums to add to his own illustrious portfolio.Among the brand new additions is an extension to his Enclave line. AJ created the original Habano-wrapped beauty with the help …
Read More

CAO Flathead

John Expert Picks: Holiday Classics Expert Pick
This unique '95' rated gem is full-bodied with a beautifully complex profile. Flathead's Nicaraguan and Dominican fillers are bound with a well-fermented Connecticut Broadleaf wrapper. Notes of black pepper, cocoa, and earth are nothing short of a holiday treat.…
Read More

CAO Fuma em Corda

John Exotic Flavors From CAO
CAO may be one of the most adventurous cigar brands in the business. Its blends take enthusiasts off the beaten path with tobaccos procured in regions not often utilized by most cigar brands. A prime example of this is CAO’s Fuma Em Corda, literally translated to “smoke on a rope.” Named for a process native to Brazil, part of Fuma Em Corda’s blend of long fillers consists of Brazilian Arapiraca …
Read More

Rocky Patel Super Ligero

John Expert Picks: After Dinner Powerhouses Expert Pick
As advertised, Rocky Patel Super Ligero is brimming with Nicaraguan and Costa Rican triple ligero fillers, all hidden by a St. Augustine Habano wrapper. A complex profile with notes of leather and spice make this premium bold, balanced, and an absolute pleasure after a big meal.…
Read More

Macanudo Inspirado Black

John A Bold Blend From Macanudo
You’d be hard pressed to find an enthusiast who hasn’t sampled one of Macanudo’s many blends. You’d be even more hard pressed to find one who hasn’t at least heard of the brand during its nearly 50 year run. The brand started out in Jamaica in the late 60s, but moved to the Dominican Republic a few years later where it set down permanent roots. At first, the cigars were mellow and packed with …
Read More

Brick House Connecticut

John A Mellower Brick House
Easily one of J.C. Newman’s most popular cigar lines, Brick House has cornered the market on top notch cigars at an unbeatable price. Each blend is beautifully balanced with a pleasing aromas, and a throng of satisfying tasting notes. The original Brick House cigar was well-received by both fans and critics, and earned a well-deserved spot in Cigar Aficionado’s top 25 cigars of 2010. The maduro …
Read More

Perla del Mar

John Expert Picks: Hip to be Squared Expert Pick
A gorgeous offering from JC Newman. Perla del Mar’s golden brown wrapper is pristine. An Ecuadorian Connecticut leaf masks long-fillers from three growing regions in Nicaragua, bringing about decadent notes of cedar, caramel, and cream. Without a doubt, Perla del Mar is one of my favorite mellow-bodied cigars.…
Read More
100% satisfaction guaranteed
Get the Latest Deals!
Sign Up for email