The Expert Review Library

Showing -559--550 of 579 Reviews
  • Aladino Corojo - Lindsay
    Lindsay
    04/11/2024
    expert picks logo

    Justo Eiroa of JRE Tobacco came to our offices a few months back, handed out some cigars, and after one Aladino Corojo, I was sold: I can’t believe I never had an Aladino before! This Honduran puro is now part of my regular rotation, with its notes of baking spice, cedar, and white pepper rich on the palate thanks to its Corojo wrapper.

  • Punch Golden Era - Bella
    Bella
    01/05/2024
    expert picks logo

    For me personally, I enjoy spice but in a tempered way. Punch Golden Era is refined, and after I smoked one Churchill with water, I wanted to amplify the underlying cinnamon note, so I grabbed another cigar and some Sazerac Rye. The candied spice note in my whiskey harmonized perfectly with this blend!


  • PunchGolden Era - Kelly
    Kelly
    01/05/2024
    expert picks logo

    I’ve enjoyed other Punch cigars regularly, but Golden Era having received a ‘90’ rating upon release from Cigar Aficionado caught my attention. The Honduran Havana Seed Corojo wrapper was as silky on the palate as it was in my hands; perhaps the most enjoyable experience was each nuance never overpowering the other.

  • Punch Golden Era - Oscar
    Oscar
    01/05/2024
    expert picks logo

    Julio and Justo Eiroa used non-hybrid seeds, meaning what grew the leaves for this blend genetically originate from Cuba without any cross-straining: this is almost like being able to enjoy a classic Cuban-style cigar without any of the legal issues. Of the three vitolas, the Toro is my preference day or night.

  • Punch Golden Era
    Lindsay
    01/05/2024
    expert picks logo

    If you know anything about the history of the El Corojo farm in Cuba, then you’ll understand why what the Eiroa family did with this blend is so important. The adherence to old Cuban tradition transplanted to Honduras resulted in a multi-dimensional cigar that speaks cleanly on the palate. A perfect pairing with my afternoon coffee.

  • Crowned Heads Mil Dias (NEW Expert Picks) - Kelly L
    Kelly
    09/29/2023
    expert picks logo

    Fun fact: The ‘M’ logo on the band is not only an abbreviation for Mil Días, but it’s also the Roman numeral for 1,000. Since the cigar’s name literally means 1,000 days in Spanish, you can tell the Crowned Heads team really put a lot of thought into every possible detail for this blend.


  • Crowned Heads Mil Dias (NEW Expert Picks) - Lindsay H
    Lindsay
    09/29/2023
    expert picks logo

    If good things come to those who wait, then I’d happily wait 1,000 days for these cigars. My preference is for the Double Robusto, as I enjoy the more nuanced interplay between sweeter and spicier notes in that vitola. You’ll often catch me celebrating “Mil Días Mondays” to start my week off right, and I suggest you do the same!


  • Crowned Heads Mil Dias (NEW Expert Picks) - Oscar
    Oscar
    09/29/2023
    expert picks logo

    A seamless Ecuador Habano wrapper, Nicaraguan binder, and long-fillers from Costa Rica, Nicaragua, and Peru: this blend was well thought-out. I prefer the Sublime size, but also how this cigar never overpowers my palate while providing a constant evolution of flavor. Cedar, nuts, sweet cream, earth, spices, and cocoa pair well with coffee in the morning and bourbon at night.


  • Crowned Heads Mil Dias (NEW Expert Picks) - Bella
    Bella
    09/29/2023
    expert picks logo

    There’s something wonderful about a blend which can be appreciated by enthusiasts of all levels – it’s also a rare occurrence in today’s market. Someone more experienced will pick up on its complexity that firmly remains balanced, while a lesser-experienced individual will revel in its profile, appearance, and burn. Mil Días grabs your attention and never lets go.


  • Kelly -Rocky Patel White Label
    Kelly
    05/29/2023
    expert picks logo

    Debuting in 2021, Rocky's White Label has flown under the radar a bit. Is it any wonder? With an award-winning portfolio like Rocky's, it can be hard to stand out. But something tells me this gem is about to get noticed. A combination of Nicaraguan and Honduran tobaccos is finished with a silky-smooth Connecticut Shade wrapper. Expect notes of cedar, earth, and hints of vanilla.

Our Experts

KEVIN - Preferred Cigar Profile: Mellow-Medium MIKE - Preferred Cigar Profile: Medium JOE - Preferred Cigar Profile: Medium-Full BELLA - Preferred Cigar Profile: Medium-Full OSCAR- Preferred Cigar Profile: Medium-Full KELLY - Preferred Cigar Profile: Medium-Full