The Expert Review Library

Showing -349--340 of 579 Reviews
  • Michael - Ave Maria Barbarossa
    Michael
    04/05/2018
    expert picks logo

    Blended by AJ Fernandez himself, Ave Maria is one of the finest cigars available. Showcasing an Ecuador Habano wrapper with a Nicaraguan long-leaf tobacco, this is an exquisite blend. Well-balanced with a creamy profile, Ave Maria is one of my favorites.

  • Bella - Romeo y Julieta Reserve Churchill
    Bella
    04/05/2018
    expert picks logo

    Reserve is another impressive offering from Romeo y Julieta! Full in body, this cigar is bursting with flavor. Expertly blended with Nicaraguan and Honduran long-fillers swaddled beneath a dark and oily Nicaraguan wrapper, expect hints of earth, spice, and sweetness.

  • Tim - Gilberto Oliva Reserva Blanc 750
    Tim
    04/05/2018
    expert picks logo

    Gilberto Reserva Blanc is Oliva’s newest release since 2012, and it’s well worth the wait. This mellow to medium-bodied blend sports a golden Ecuador Connecticut wrapper which encases Nicaraguan long-leaf. A classic Connecticut profile with notes of cashew, cream, and a bit of graham cracker.

  • Andy - Man O’ War Damnation Robusto
    Andrew
    02/22/2018
    expert picks logo

    Of course, I picked another AJ and it’s fantastic! Man O’ War Damnation is a strong blend that opens with spice, leather, and oak, but mellows with coffee notes and some cherry on the finish. Make sure to complete your warrior training before taking on Damnation.

  • Michael- Lucious Lyon No.2 Torpedo
    Staff Review
    02/22/2018
    expert picks logo

    Named for the main character on Fox’s TV series Empire, Lucious Lyon is smooth as silk and mellow. A true classic Connecticut blend, this premium offers rich notes of leather, cream, nuts, and a slight spice on the finish. A great cigar for any time of day.  

  • Bella- Alec Bradley Prensado Lost Art
    Bella
    02/22/2018
    expert picks logo

    Prensado Lost Art is masterfully made with a Honduran Corojo wrapper and a core of 5 different Honduran and Nicaraguan tobaccos. Expect complex flavors of white pepper, dark chocolate, earthiness, and hints of coffee. This bold and beautifully balanced treat is aromatic and delicious. Kudos Alec Bradley!  

  • Dan- Drew Estate Undercrown Shade Gran Toro
    Daniel
    02/22/2018
    expert picks logo

    Drew Estate Undercrown Shade is a Nicaraguan-made gem which sports a silky Connecticut Shade wrapper. Rich with a velvety creaminess that stays with you throughout, this cigar has notes of cedar, earth, and black pepper. Undercrown Shade is a shining example of a medium-bodied cigar.

  • John - Victor Sinclair Serie '55' Imperial Connecticut Robusto
    John
    02/22/2018
    expert picks logo

    This cigar is an easygoing blend that never disappoints. Decadent Dominican long-fillers are encased by a smooth Connecticut wrapper. Satisfying notes of leather, spice, and cedar greet the palate and pair nicely with a morning coffee. One of Victor Sinclair’s crowning achievements.

  • Daniel - Oliva Serie 'G' Maduro Belicoso
    Daniel
    12/28/2017
    expert picks logo

    Before this review, I enjoyed Oliva cigars on occasion, but now I find myself in love with the Oliva Serie 'G' Maduro. Its dark, oily Connecticut Broadleaf wrapper and Nicaraguan long-fillers reward my palate with a slightly nutty profile and notes of earthiness, fruit, cocoa, and coffee!

  • John - CAO Flathead V660 Carb
    John
    12/28/2017
    expert picks logo

    This is not only one of my top picks for 2017, it's also one of my go-to cigars. This '95' rated box-pressed beauty sports a well-aged Connecticut Broadleaf wrapper with Nicaraguan and Dominican long-fillers beneath. Its notes of cocoa, black pepper, and earth are always an absolute pleasure.

Our Experts

KEVIN - Preferred Cigar Profile: Mellow-Medium MIKE - Preferred Cigar Profile: Medium JOE - Preferred Cigar Profile: Medium-Full BELLA - Preferred Cigar Profile: Medium-Full OSCAR- Preferred Cigar Profile: Medium-Full KELLY - Preferred Cigar Profile: Medium-Full