The Expert Review Library

Showing -19--10 of 40 Reviews
  • Kelly - Alec Bradley Prensado Robusto
    Kelly
    05/15/2020
    expert picks logo

    This box-pressed beauty by Alan Rubin is what comes to mind every time I'm in need of a premium that hits the spot. '96' rated, this lush blend burns slow and even, making way to a palatable treat filled with toasty nuances of leather, earth, and hints of chocolate. Spicy on the forefront, this premium offsets its power with some sweet nuances.

  • Lindsay - My Father No.1 Robusto
    Lindsay
    05/15/2020
    expert picks logo

    Many covet Cuban cigars, but I covet Nicaraguan made by Cuban ex-pats such as Jose Pepín García. '94' rated, this blend exemplifies excellence in quality, complexity, and delivery. A Cuban-seed Rosado wrapper plus Nicaraguan long-fillers equals full flavors of earth, leather, cashew, coffee bean, and an undertone of spice with a long, full finish.

  • Michael - Don Pepin Garcia Blue Generosos
    Michael
    05/15/2020
    expert picks logo

    Don Pepín García Blue is a smooth and rich powerhouse with a '93' rating from legendary Jose Pepín García. Blended in classic Cuban tradition at the prestigious My Father Factory, this all-Nicaraguan blend has notes of red peppers, cocoa, cedar, delivering a rich and spicy finish with a perfect draw. Pair perfectly with a single malt Scotch.

  • Bella - Manuel Quesada 70th Anniversary Belicoso
    Staff Review
    05/15/2020
    expert picks logo

    Manuel Quesada 70th Anniversary is a special tribute to Manuel Quesada Jr., and is specifically blended by the master himself, Manuel Quesada. This cigar has a spectacular flavor starting with its balanced touches of Nicaraguan spice and earthy, Dominican flavors, with subtle hints of creamy undertones.

  • Tim - Southern Draw Jacob's Ladder Toro
    Tim
    05/15/2020
    expert picks logo

    It's time to climb to a new level of flavor. Made by AJ Fernandez in Estelí, wrapped in a dark PA Broadleaf with potent long-fillers from Nicaragua, Jacob's Ladder is loaded with spices and savory notes of charred meat, red pepper, and leather. Ascend to a better tasting blend with this all-star from Robert Holt and Southern Draw.

  • Bella - Caldwell The King Is Dead The Last Payday
    Bella
    04/03/2020
    expert picks logo

    One of Caldwell's finest offerings, earning a '93' rating—this balanced, medium-bodied smoke delivers on both complexity and consistency. Rare Dominican tobaccos blended together smooth with a toothy Dominican Negrito wrapper atop creates an earthy flavor complemented by slight nuances of cocoa, and just a hint of spice.

  • Kelly - CAO Consigliere Associate
    Kelly
    04/03/2020
    expert picks logo

    Smoke like a boss with CAO Consigliere! This tri-country blend of long-fillers are dressed in a dark, oily Brazilian Mata Fina maduro wrapper. Heavy on the palate, a nutty core is surrounded with hearty notes of earth and slight hints of cinnamon. Solid construction with an effortless draw, this premium is a bonafide showstopper!

  • Lindsay - Montecristo Nicaragua Toro
    Lindsay
    04/03/2020
    expert picks logo

    Nicaraguan puros are some of my favorite cigars on the market, and the elegant look of this line extension exudes premium. A collaboration between AJ Fernandez and Rafael Nodal has resulted in notes of dark chocolate, espresso bean, dried berries, and cedar in a medium to full-bodied package. Supremely balanced.

  • Michael - La Aurora Preferidos Platinum No.2
    Michael
    04/03/2020
    expert picks logo

    La Aurora Preferidos Cameroon Platinum is a '91' rated smoke that should be a staple in any humidor. This beautifully-crafted figurado features a toothy Cameroon wrapper and specially aged Dominican binder and multinational filler. It's then aged several years in oak barrels, giving it notes of coffee and chocolate with a smooth, sweet, yet spicy finish.

  • Tim - La Barba Ricochet Cru Mexi-Sol Gran Robusto
    Staff Review
    04/03/2020
    expert picks logo

    I haven't had to worry about going to the barber for quite some time now, so when I saw a brand called La Barba, I jumped at the chance to 'get a new do'. Their Ricochet Cru Mexi-Sol blend is a beauty to behold, and as bold and satisfying as any on the market today.

Our Experts

expert picks expert picks expert picks expert picks expert picks expert picks