Your web browser is no longer supported. is committed to providing you with the best web experience possible.

Expert Picks: Fall Classics

With hundreds of cigars on the shelves to choose from these days, it’s easy to forget about some of the more classic brands. This time around our experts dug up some old standby favorites and present Expert Picks: Fall Classics. These cigars have stood the test of time and remain top-sellers year in and year out. Including mild, medium, and full-bodied blends, there’s something for everyone here. So bring in the fall season with some classics and discover why these cigars will never get old. These 5, 10, or 15-count sampler feature our expert’s recommendations. Each sampler contains: Trinidad Reserve, Macanudo Café, Punch Bareknuckle, CAO Italia, and Rocky Patel Vintage 2003 Cameroon.

Trinidad Reserve

You can taste the Cuban tradition in this Honduras blended Trinidad Reserve. The Ecuadorian Habano wrapper encases a robust blend of Nicaraguan and Honduran fillers that make this full-bodied cigar smooth and complex with a hint of sweetness. This is a great cigar for after lunch. Just break off the pigtail, light it up and enjoy.
Shop Now

Macanudo Cafe

This Dominican blend is a classic and one of the world’s best-selling cigars. If you thought mild-bodied cigars weren’t your thing, there’s a good chance Macanudo Café will prove you wrong. It’s one of the most consistent cigars ever made and delivers an ultra-smooth experience from start to finish. Perfect for any occasion, Macanudo Café offers creamy notes of almonds, cedar, and vanilla.
Shop Now


I know a thing or two about getting punched, let’s just say I have one of those faces.  That said, this Bareknuckle blend from Punch is enjoyable through and through. Featuring an oily and redolent sungrown Ecuadorian Habano wrapper and aged ligero long-leaf fillers, Punch Bareknuckle provides layers of spicy nuances and a strong yet pleasant aroma. You’ll be glad you got in the ring with this hard hitter.
Shop Now

CAO Italia

A favorite from CAO’s popular world collection, Italia utilizes a habano seed that was brought to Italy from Cuba nearly fifty years ago. Featuring a complex blend of Italian, Nicaraguan, and Peruvian fillers topped off with a Honduran binder and wrapper, this full-bodied blend offers a unique aroma and flavor you won’t get anywhere else. I often find myself pairing this classic with a hearty red wine. You can’t go wrong CAO Italia.
Shop Now

Rocky Patel Vintage '03 Cameroon

Vintage 2003 begins with a perfectly balanced blend of Nicaraguan and Dominican long-fillers that offer a wonderful aroma and flavor. The icing on the cake is a Cameroon wrapper, aged for eight years, which adds a nice hint of sweetness with some lighter notes of pepper and cedar. Enjoying this cigar with your favorite Octoberfest style lager will make for a great evening on any fall day.
Shop Now