A forum for cigar lovers.

Welcome to Cigar.com Sign in | Join | Help
in
 
  Home Cigars Samplers Gifts Accessories Sales Community Info Account

Mystery Stick Game

Last post 02-03-2012, 11:24 PM by Mephisto. 1419 replies.
Page 32 of 95 (1,420 items)   « First ... < Previous 30 31 32 33 34 Next > ... Last »
Sort Posts: Previous
  • Re: Mystery Cigar 'A'

     11-16-2009, 10:26 PM

    laker1963:
    {Buzzer sounds} Nope That one was an Alec Bradley Maxx Brazil. This is a fairly new stick for me.Only had a couple. They are tasty.
    I knew that couldn't be right. Still a good cigar. Thanks again.
    "As I grow to understand life less and less, I learn to love it more and more." - Jules Renard
  • Re: Mystery Cigar 'B'

     11-16-2009, 10:40 PM

    I started cigar b tonight after a meeting and smoked it on the way home. Before even lighting it up, I knew I would have trouble identifying it. This torpedo (about 6 x 54) had a light brown color wrapper that was streaky and somewhat oily. I appeared to be a bit fragile as it suffered a few cracks before and during smoking it. Regardless of the wrapper cracking, it burned impeccably and the first ash held on past the two inch mark. It started with a bit of spice but mellowed out to a creamier smoke with hints of wood and spice. It was a prolly medium in body, but was full of flavor and was constructed magnificently. I can not put my finger on anything that stood out in any past experience so I have to guess at this.

    I'm guessing a CAO Criollo.
    "As I grow to understand life less and less, I learn to love it more and more." - Jules Renard
  • Re:

     11-16-2009, 11:56 PM

    • Joined on 08-25-2009
    • Vancouver, BC
    • Posts 431
    • Top 200 Contributor
    Alien has a package headed my way, but it won't arrive for a while, and any package I send won't arrive for a while.... so in the spirit of the game and to keep things moving, I utter the words:

    Who wants to be my mooch?

    Shaun
    Senior VP, Department of Redundancy Department
  • Re: Re:

     11-17-2009, 12:19 AM

    Don't want to hijack Shaun's mooch proposition, but I do have something to bring up in regards to the game.

    In the interest of keeping this to a low level of confusion, I'm wondering if we shouldn't wait until one person does all their guessing for the next person to start. My reasoning for this is that right now three packages are making their way towards the next guessers...I don't know when Tat sent mine, so it could land tomorrow or who knows when. I sent Tony's today and Shaun has one coming. If all of us were to start guessing within days of each other, it might lead to some confusion. I'm not proposing a halt to the mooching/sending of packs, but just an order to who guesses next. Any thoughts?
    "Beliefs are neat. Cherish them, but don't share them like they're the truth" Bill Hicks
  • Re: Re:

     11-17-2009, 12:32 AM

    • Joined on 08-25-2009
    • Vancouver, BC
    • Posts 431
    • Top 200 Contributor
    Good thought Joe, luckily things will slow down on their own. Alien's package won't arrive to me for at least two weeks, and my package won't get to it's recipient for at least two weeks. That's why I offered mine up so quickly. Maybe the person who takes me up can hold off for a bit.

    Shaun
    Senior VP, Department of Redundancy Department
  • Re: Re:

     11-17-2009, 12:39 AM

    That's a good point. Maybe my concerns are unwarranted...we'll have to see how it all plays out. I certainly don't want to disrupt the game since it has been working pretty well so far.
    "Beliefs are neat. Cherish them, but don't share them like they're the truth" Bill Hicks
  • Re: Mystery Cigar 'B'

     11-17-2009, 2:29 PM

    bbc020:
    I started cigar b tonight after a meeting and smoked it on the way home. Before even lighting it up, I knew I would have trouble identifying it. This torpedo (about 6 x 54) had a light brown color wrapper that was streaky and somewhat oily. I appeared to be a bit fragile as it suffered a few cracks before and during smoking it. Regardless of the wrapper cracking, it burned impeccably and the first ash held on past the two inch mark. It started with a bit of spice but mellowed out to a creamier smoke with hints of wood and spice. It was a prolly medium in body, but was full of flavor and was constructed magnificently. I can not put my finger on anything that stood out in any past experience so I have to guess at this.

    I'm guessing a CAO Criollo.
    just want to bump this for doug
    "As I grow to understand life less and less, I learn to love it more and more." - Jules Renard
  • Re: Mystery Cigar 'B'

     11-17-2009, 2:39 PM

    bbc020:
    bbc020:
    I started cigar b tonight after a meeting and smoked it on the way home. Before even lighting it up, I knew I would have trouble identifying it. This torpedo (about 6 x 54) had a light brown color wrapper that was streaky and somewhat oily. I appeared to be a bit fragile as it suffered a few cracks before and during smoking it. Regardless of the wrapper cracking, it burned impeccably and the first ash held on past the two inch mark. It started with a bit of spice but mellowed out to a creamier smoke with hints of wood and spice. It was a prolly medium in body, but was full of flavor and was constructed magnificently. I can not put my finger on anything that stood out in any past experience so I have to guess at this.

    I'm guessing a CAO Criollo.
    just want to bump this for doug
    EEEEEW, 0 for 2 Brandon. The second stick was a Rocky Patel Sungrown. These are very good with some age on them. I found the same as you mentioned tho, they do have rather delicate wrappers that are very fragile when aged some and they break or flake quite easily.
    I can't wait to see what you think of #3.




  • Re: Mystery Cigar 'B'

     11-17-2009, 2:46 PM

    laker1963:
    bbc020:
    bbc020:
    I started cigar b tonight after a meeting and smoked it on the way home. Before even lighting it up, I knew I would have trouble identifying it. This torpedo (about 6 x 54) had a light brown color wrapper that was streaky and somewhat oily. I appeared to be a bit fragile as it suffered a few cracks before and during smoking it. Regardless of the wrapper cracking, it burned impeccably and the first ash held on past the two inch mark. It started with a bit of spice but mellowed out to a creamier smoke with hints of wood and spice. It was a prolly medium in body, but was full of flavor and was constructed magnificently. I can not put my finger on anything that stood out in any past experience so I have to guess at this.

    I'm guessing a CAO Criollo.
    just want to bump this for doug
    EEEEEW, 0 for 2 Brandon. The second stick was a Rocky Patel Sungrown. These are very good with some age on them. I found the same as you mentioned tho, they do have rather delicate wrappers that are very fragile when aged some and they break or flake quite easily.
    I can't wait to see what you think of #3.
    Can't say I'm too embarrased. i've only had the Sungrown on one other occasion. This one was far better than the previous one I had. It must have been the age. I do appreciate it though. I should be firing up cigar C in about 20 minutes or so.
    "As I grow to understand life less and less, I learn to love it more and more." - Jules Renard
  • Re: Mystery Cigar 'C'

     11-17-2009, 4:44 PM

    Cigar C seems to be the most complex of the cigars Laker sent. This box pressed toro measures in around 6"x 48 and has an oily reddish hued wrapper. The prelight draw had a noticeable cocoa/coffee-ish hint to it and it started off pretty strong with some pepper and sweetness. This stick suffered from some burn issues and required some touch ups throughout. I thought I noticed some nicarauguan flavor in there, but that disappated and went to a more earthy quality to it making me think more honduran. It remained pretty peppery and sweet and had some fruity notes to it. It remained full bodied and got more flavorful as the cigar burned down. As I got down to the last third, the pepper became even more noticeable, while sweet notes continued to dance around it.

    While there were some recognizeable qualities to this cigar, I don't think I've had it before. So, once again, I'll have to make a guess.

    With the shape, wrapper, and flavor profile in mind, I'm going to guess the Gurkha Micro Batch VH-7
    "As I grow to understand life less and less, I learn to love it more and more." - Jules Renard
  • Re: Re:

     11-17-2009, 5:41 PM

    • Joined on 01-08-2009
    • San Francisco
    • Posts 651
    • Top 150 Contributor
    TheShaun:
    Alien has a package headed my way, but it won't arrive for a while, and any package I send won't arrive for a while.... so in the spirit of the game and to keep things moving, I utter the words:

    Who wants to be my mooch?

    I do I do! Since I had such a great experience the last time I played I ready for another go!



    "All things are possible through faith in The Beard."
    - j0z3r 1/15/2010


    pure.refreshing.bacon.
  • Re: Mystery Cigar 'C'

     11-17-2009, 7:41 PM

    bbc020:
    Cigar C seems to be the most complex of the cigars Laker sent. This box pressed toro measures in around 6"x 48 and has an oily reddish hued wrapper. The prelight draw had a noticeable cocoa/coffee-ish hint to it and it started off pretty strong with some pepper and sweetness. This stick suffered from some burn issues and required some touch ups throughout. I thought I noticed some nicarauguan flavor in there, but that disappated and went to a more earthy quality to it making me think more honduran. It remained pretty peppery and sweet and had some fruity notes to it. It remained full bodied and got more flavorful as the cigar burned down. As I got down to the last third, the pepper became even more noticeable, while sweet notes continued to dance around it.

    While there were some recognizeable qualities to this cigar, I don't think I've had it before. So, once again, I'll have to make a guess.

    With the shape, wrapper, and flavor profile in mind, I'm going to guess the Gurkha Micro Batch VH-7
    On the nose sir ! Both your guess and your review. These are a pretty complex stick. Full bore all the way and changing flavors and nuances thruout. Sorry to hear about the burn issues. Are these sticks because of their smaller gauge something you would not normally try? Being a bigger guy I mean...

    I thought of that after I sent them out, but then I rationalised that you would have a lot less of a challenge with the bigger gauge sticks. I know you have tried a vast number of different brands and lines, so I was hoping to send you out some things you wouldn't normally opt for yourself.




  • Re: Mystery Cigar 'C'

     11-17-2009, 10:46 PM

    laker1963:
    bbc020:
    Cigar C seems to be the most complex of the cigars Laker sent. This box pressed toro measures in around 6"x 48 and has an oily reddish hued wrapper. The prelight draw had a noticeable cocoa/coffee-ish hint to it and it started off pretty strong with some pepper and sweetness. This stick suffered from some burn issues and required some touch ups throughout. I thought I noticed some nicarauguan flavor in there, but that disappated and went to a more earthy quality to it making me think more honduran. It remained pretty peppery and sweet and had some fruity notes to it. It remained full bodied and got more flavorful as the cigar burned down. As I got down to the last third, the pepper became even more noticeable, while sweet notes continued to dance around it.

    While there were some recognizeable qualities to this cigar, I don't think I've had it before. So, once again, I'll have to make a guess.

    With the shape, wrapper, and flavor profile in mind, I'm going to guess the Gurkha Micro Batch VH-7
    On the nose sir ! Both your guess and your review. These are a pretty complex stick. Full bore all the way and changing flavors and nuances thruout. Sorry to hear about the burn issues. Are these sticks because of their smaller gauge something you would not normally try? Being a bigger guy I mean...

    I thought of that after I sent them out, but then I rationalised that you would have a lot less of a challenge with the bigger gauge sticks. I know you have tried a vast number of different brands and lines, so I was hoping to send you out some things you wouldn't normally opt for yourself.
    You are correct in choosing sticks that I wouldn't normally smoke. Not because of the ring guage...I actually enjoy smaller ring guaged smokes a bit more. I'm not much of a Gurkha fan and that keeps me from trying every one of there seemingly growing collection of cigars. I was impressed with the VH-7 though. I do enjoy a few of the RP lines, but haven't tried quantity of many, they normally don't stand out to me much. The sun grown you sent me falls in there, it was good, but nothing I'm doing handsprings over. I'm still pretty new to the AB lines, and have enjoyed the ones I have tried, including the Maxx Brazil you sent. I appreciate the sticks and the opportunity to try some new stuff blind.
    "As I grow to understand life less and less, I learn to love it more and more." - Jules Renard
  • Re: Re:

     11-17-2009, 11:07 PM

    • Joined on 08-25-2009
    • Vancouver, BC
    • Posts 431
    • Top 200 Contributor
    Jdorais:
    TheShaun:
    Alien has a package headed my way, but it won't arrive for a while, and any package I send won't arrive for a while.... so in the spirit of the game and to keep things moving, I utter the words:

    Who wants to be my mooch?

    I do I do! Since I had such a great experience the last time I played I ready for another go!

    PM sent!

    Shaun
    Senior VP, Department of Redundancy Department
  • Re: Re:

     11-17-2009, 11:21 PM

    • Joined on 01-08-2009
    • San Francisco
    • Posts 651
    • Top 150 Contributor
    TheShaun:
    Jdorais:
    TheShaun:
    Alien has a package headed my way, but it won't arrive for a while, and any package I send won't arrive for a while.... so in the spirit of the game and to keep things moving, I utter the words:

    Who wants to be my mooch?

    I do I do! Since I had such a great experience the last time I played I ready for another go!

    PM sent!

    back at ya!

    "All things are possible through faith in The Beard."
    - j0z3r 1/15/2010


    pure.refreshing.bacon.
Page 32 of 95 (1,420 items)   « First ... < Previous 30 31 32 33 34 Next > ... Last »
View as RSS news feed in XML