I have only tried two so far, the Cusano and the RP. Kind of a toss-up as to which I liked better. I just got some of the Matasa too, but going to let them sit. I agree that the regular RP are better. Actually got a few new ones of thoses I am waiting to try too (signature, fusion and double maduro)
BTW - where in Chicago area are you?
Haven't tried a Graycliff yet, but would have to agree based on what I have seen with the list prices. Have had a great deal of success with picking up exceptional bargains on the auction sites.
I live in Naperville.
Yesterday for me was a CAO Black Mosaic and a HDM Tradicion. CAO was ok, with all the hype I have seen thought it would be better. Maybe the size (6.5 x 44) wasn't the best for this particular smoke. Really liked the HDM though. Excellent construction and burn, a real good medium strength cigar
jpen74:I am going to smoke a Gurkha Beast tonight. I love this cigar.